In depth analysis “On the Face of It” by Susan

Susan Hill's captivating short story "On the Face of It" came to life in 2008— a literary work that paints a vivid picture of loneliness, the dichotomy of appearances versus reality, and the strength found in human connection. Featuring two characters, Mr. Lamb and Derry, meeting in a garden and bridging the gap of their differences, an unexpected friendship ensues. Here, we dive deep into the intricate narrative of the story. 

Plot Summary:

The story begins with Derry, a young boy who has a disfigured face due to an acid accident. He spends his time in a garden, alone and isolated, because other children avoid him. One day, Mr. Lamb, an old man who has lost a leg and is physically impaired, approaches Derry. The two strike up a conversation, and their unlikely friendship blossoms.

 

As they communicate, it becomes evident that both characters are lonely and isolated due to their physical appearances. They form a bond that transcends their differences, finding comfort and understanding in each other's company. Mr. Lamb, with his wisdom and experience, becomes a mentor figure to Derry, giving him hope and a sense of belonging.

 

Themes:
 

Loneliness and Isolation:

 

Loneliness is a central theme in the story. Both Mr. Lamb and Derry are marginalized by society due to their physical appearances. They are isolated from their peers, which leads them to seek companionship in each other. The garden serves as a metaphorical space where these two outsiders find solace and understanding.

 

Appearance vs. Reality:

 The story highlights how appearances can be deceptive. Both characters are judged based on their external appearances, but their interactions reveal the depth of their personalities. Mr. Lamb's amputated leg and Derry's scarred face are not indicative of their true worth as individuals.

 

Human Relationship:

The power of human relationship is another significant theme. Despite their differences, Mr. Lamb and Derry forge a meaningful friendship that transcends physical appearances. Their companionship provides them with a sense of purpose and alleviates their loneliness.

 

Character Analysis:

 

Derry:

 Derry is a young boy who has suffered a disfiguring accident, leaving him with a scarred face. He embodies the theme of isolation and loneliness, as he is shunned by other children due to his appearance. Derry's initial reluctance to engage with Mr. Lamb reflects his fear of rejection. However, his interactions with Mr. Lamb bring out his vulnerability, curiosity, and need for companionship.

 

Mr. Lamb:

Mr. Lamb, an elderly man, has lost a leg and is physically impaired. He exudes wisdom and empathy. He serves as a mentor to Derry, offering guidance and understanding. Despite his physical limitations, Mr. Lamb's openness and kindness make him an endearing character. His own experiences of being marginalized enable him to empathize with Derry's struggles.

 

Setting:

 

The garden where Mr. Lamb and Derry meet is a crucial setting that symbolizes a space of renewal and growth. It becomes a safe haven for both characters, where they can escape the judgment and isolation they face in the outside world. The garden's natural beauty contrasts with the ugliness of societal prejudices.

 

Style and Tone:

 

Hill's writing style is characterized by simplicity and understated emotion. The tone of the story is poignant and bittersweet, as it addresses the challenges faced by both characters. The dialogues between Mr. Lamb and Derry are gentle and reflective, allowing their relationship to unfold gradually.

 

Conclusion:

 

"On the Face of It" is a moving exploration of the human capacity for empathy and connection. Through the friendship between Mr. Lamb and Derry, Susan Hill highlights the resilience of the human spirit and challenges readers to look beyond external appearances. The story serves as a reminder that true companionship can be found in unexpected places and that shared experiences can bridge the gap between seemingly different individuals.